The 18-footers in sailing history
For most of the history of sail, a boat of a given size went about as fast as any other. Hulls were heavy and sails were modest, because a boat had to live through the sudden squall. In Higher Performance Sailing (2008), the designer and sailing scientist Frank Bethwaite traces four changes that broke that rule, and Sydney Harbour was at the front of two of them. The club's boats belong to the first.
The crew as ballast
The first change belonged to the nineteenth century and to two harbours on opposite sides of the world. Around New York the sandbaggers, broad, shallow boats under enormous rigs, carried bags of sand or gravel that the crew heaved to the windward side on every tack. On Sydney Harbour the open boats did the same thing with people. A big open boat carried a crew of a dozen or more, who piled onto the windward gunwale to hold up a rig far bigger than the hull, and the same crew set the extras downwind: square sails, water sails and the ringtail.
Both kinds of boat were faster than the yachts of their day, length for length. Both drew crowds, and both drew betting.
“If you can’t beat them, ban them”
That is Bethwaite’s test of a real jump in speed: watch how the establishment reacts. In New York the amateur, or Corinthian, yacht clubs answered with rules against shifting ballast and professional helmsmen, and by the 1890s the sandbaggers had faded from the harbour.
Sydney had its own version, though not over speed. In December 1891, six weeks after this club’s first race, the committee of the National Regatta ruled that a boat could carry no mark on its sail but its number. The men who spoke for the rule came from rival open boat clubs, and their objections were about betting and money prizes, which is to say about professionalism, the other half of New York’s complaint. The Squadron answered with a regatta of its own.
Planing, and why Sydney waited
The second change was the planing hull: a light, flat boat that skims over the water instead of pushing through it. It came in the 1890s. In Auckland the Logan brothers built light boats with no ballast at all, and in July 1898 the Parnell Sailing Club named its new class of them Patikis, the Māori word for a flatfish. In Montreal, G. Herrick Duggan’s low, flat Glencairn won the Seawanhaka Cup from its New York holders in 1896, the first race by 47 minutes, and his club held the cup until 1905. On the lakes of the American Midwest the scow took over.
The new type reached Sydney quickly. The Logans’ one-rater Mercia won the first race of the intercolonial one-rater championship at Auckland in December 1898, against Sydney’s Bronzewing IV, and was shipped to Sydney two months later. When this club opened its racing to all boats of 18 feet and over, in 1899, it took in several raters, and in the 1900 to 1901 season Mercia was on its register.
Sydney’s 18-footers still did not follow for a generation. Bethwaite puts it down to the harbour. The racing went up and down it, into and away from the north-east sea breeze; the headlands and islands broke the reaches into short legs; and wind against tide raised a chop that slowed a flat hull to windward. A boat built to plane had little room to do it, and the heavily crewed boat with its cloud of extras kept winning.
The change came in the 1930s, with narrow, light boats from Brisbane such as Aberdare. The Squadron closed its register to new boats in December 1933, and at the New Year of 1934 to 1935 a breakaway league was announced to race them from Double Bay. In January 1938 that league, whose secretary was J. J. Giltinan, sailed the first world championship of the class on Sydney Harbour.
The fleet is the timeline
The club’s replicas span those years. Scot (1906) and Britannia (1919) are the big-crew, big-sail boats of the first change. Yendys (1925) and Tangalooma (1930) come from the last years before the split, and Aberdare (1932) and The Mistake (1933) are the narrow boats that caused it. Australia IV (1943), Australia and Top Weight (1946) and Alruth (1947) carry the line through the 1940s, and Myra Too (1950) won the world title in 1951.
What the 18-footers did next
The breakaway boats became the modern 18-footers, and from the 1970s they led the third change. With wings, light hulls and big spinnakers flown from a pole at the bow, they learned what iceboat sailors already knew: a fast enough boat sails downwind faster than the wind by reaching across it. Out of that came the 49er, designed by Frank Bethwaite’s son Julian, which was chosen as an Olympic class in November 1996 and first raced at the Sydney Games in 2000, and the 29er youth boat in 1998. The fourth change, hydrofoils, came through the International Moth: by 2005 a foiling Moth had won the class’s world championship.
The Squadron took the other road. It keeps the traditional boats sailing under the rules Mark Foy wrote, so that the first change can still be seen on the water where it happened.
Where this page comes from
The frame is Frank Bethwaite’s, from chapter 1 of Higher Performance Sailing (Adlard Coles Nautical, 2008), “The Origins of High Performance”, pages 7 to 28. His Sydney material draws on Bruce Stannard’s The Blue-Water Bushmen (1981), his New Zealand material on the historian Robin Elliott, and his Montreal material on Ian Bruce. Both books are on the club’s reading list.
Each detail was checked at source. The Sydney facts come from the newspapers of the day, read on Trove: the Sydney Mail of 28 September 1878, 7 December 1895 and 16 January 1907, the Australian Town and Country Journal of 9 February 1901, the Daily Telegraph of 9 December 1933 and the Referee of 30 December 1937. The Auckland facts come from the Auckland Star of July and December 1898, the Montreal race from The Rudder of August 1896, the sandbaggers from Mystic Seaport Museum, and the Olympic and Moth dates from World Sailing and the results of the time.
Where the book and the record disagree, this page follows the record. The book says Mark Foy took the 18-footers as the club’s one class in 1891. The newspapers show the club racing boats from 14 to 26 feet at first and 18 to 26 feet from 1894, with nearly every boat an 18-footer only by 1907, and an 18-foot class already racing at the Sydney Amateur Sailing Club in 1878. The book also dates the long course from Clark Island to the Sow and Pigs to 1891. Through the 1890s the club sailed a triangle from Clark Island round Taylor Bay and Shark Island, three times round, and the Sow and Pigs course came later.